Edge awards Orange Box a perfect 10, Eye of Judgement a poor 4

[Zeus]

The scores are in from the latest edition of EGM And it is not happy reading for some publishers. Orange Box came top of the pile with a perfect score, Ratchet and Ace Combat followed in close behind with a score of 8 a piece. However, the lowest score awarded went to Eye of Judgement on the PS3 which could only manage to cook up a lowly score of a measly four.

Latest Edge scores

Orange Box (Xbox 360/PS3, EA): 10
Ratchet & Clank: Tools of Destruction (PS3, Sony): 8
Folklore (PS3, Sony): 5
Eye Of Judgement (PS3, Sony): 4
Wipeout Pulse (PSP, Sony): 7
Jericho (PS3/Xbox 360, Codemasters): 5
Conan (PS3/Xbox 360, THQ): 7
Juiced 2 (PS3/Xbox 360, THQ): 6
Monster Hunters Freedom 2 (PSP, Capcom): 7
Pursuit Force Extreme Justice (PSP, Sony): 6
Ace Combat 6 (Xbox 360, Bandai Namco): 8
Dewy's Adventure (Wii, Konami): 6
MySims (Wii, EA): 6
Freshly Picked: Tingle's Rosy Rupeeland (NDS, Nintendo): 6

News Source: <A href="http://www.xbox360only.nl/nieuwsitem.php?nid=9064" target="_blank">Xbox360only.nl</a>

[Skyline34]

Just because Eye of Judgement is a new type of game... the have to rate it ****?! I think it looks pretty cool!!

[svevin]

Just because Eye of Judgement is a new type of game... the have to rate it ****?! I think it looks pretty cool!!

they played it, you only seen some screens/trailers. who would now better if it is fun or not?

[DarylGagg]

Damn right Orange Box gets 10. The game is AWESOME! :)

[MaTiAz]

Damn, I was looking forward to Eye of Judgment, even though Playstation Eye DOES look fucking retarded.

[humpTdumpT]

Just because Eye of Judgement is a new type of game... the have to rate it ****?! I think it looks pretty cool!!

"Pretty cool" doesn't get a game a high score.

Moving along, orange box is tons of fun.

[jinqui242]

Ouch, Folklore = 5. I'm still getting it. Conan = 7, I will definitely rent this. The demo was okay.

[Desolationstorm]

The demo was funny, wasnt good but funny. I would rent conan its just fun to chop guys heads off plus a nice change of pace from fps.
halo3
bioshock
orange box
darkness
those are the 4 games I own hahah

Oh and if I knew anyone with eye of judgement Id like to see it in action its pretty cool I grew up on magic so the idea of bringing your cards to life is pretty neat. Penny-arcade seemed to enjoy the game just remarked that you need to have lighting set up in a certain way to have it work. Oh if only I actually hung out with soemone with a ps3. Everyone I know owns the same 3 systems wii, 360 and ds or one of them.

[sigma8]

they played it, you only seen some screens/trailers. who would now better if it is fun or not?

Well, Gamespot gave it a much higher score. They said it will basically only appeal to CCG fans, but it's a good CCG.

[sigma8]

Ouch, Folklore = 5. I'm still getting it. Conan = 7, I will definitely rent this. The demo was okay.

I thought the folklore demo was a lot more fun than the conan demo.. Can the games really be so opposite?

[Vesica]

Conan (PS3/Xbox 360, THQ): 7

Seriously, that game basically copied everything from god of war, even the freaking music is almost identical.